- Jian Ghomeshi was acquitted in his recent trial (see my post Jian Ghomeshi Verdict). I said there was a 65% chance that this would happen, which might have been a bit low given how strongly the conventional wisdom at the time suggested that Ghomeshi would be acquitted.
- Mike Duffy was acquitted on all counts (see my posts Mike Duffy Verdict and Mike Duffy Jail Time). I said there was a 15% chance that he would be completely acquitted, and a 65% chance that he wouldn't face jail time. The 15% estimate might have been too low, although complete acquittal didn't seem like what the conventional wisdom suggested at the time.
- The Supreme Court found mandatory minimum drug sentences unconstitutional (see my post SC Drug Sentences). Last May, I said there was a 70% chance that this would be the Supreme Court's finding, which may have been a bit conservative.
Showing posts with label Courts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Courts. Show all posts
Wednesday, 4 May 2016
Post-Mortem: Courts
Friday, 26 February 2016
AECL Case
Will the Supreme Court decide that the dismissal of Joseph Wilson was unjust?
Yes: 35%
The Supreme Court is currently in the process of deciding on the case of Joseph Wilson, an AECL employee who was fired in 2009 without cause (see articles here and here). The original adjudicator found in his favour, but the Federal Court and Federal Court of Appeal concluded that the dismissal was not unjust. I think that is what the Supreme Court will side with the lower courts, but there seems to be a fair amount of uncertainty, given the conflicting rulings.
Yes: 35%
The Supreme Court is currently in the process of deciding on the case of Joseph Wilson, an AECL employee who was fired in 2009 without cause (see articles here and here). The original adjudicator found in his favour, but the Federal Court and Federal Court of Appeal concluded that the dismissal was not unjust. I think that is what the Supreme Court will side with the lower courts, but there seems to be a fair amount of uncertainty, given the conflicting rulings.
Monday, 22 February 2016
Assisted Suicide Law v3
Before June 6th, 2016, what will happen with regards to Canada's assisted suicide law?
A new law will be passed regulating assisted suicide: 65%
The current law will be extended by the Supreme Court: 10%
The current law will expire: 25%
Since my previous post on this topic, the Supreme Court has extended the old law prohibiting assisted suicide by four months (the government wanted six months - see article here). A further extension seems unlikely to be granted, given the circumstances. It seems more likely that the current law will expire without a new law coming into force (if only for a short period of time). However, since that would reflect badly on the government, the most likely outcome is for a new law to be passed.
A new law will be passed regulating assisted suicide: 65%
The current law will be extended by the Supreme Court: 10%
The current law will expire: 25%
Since my previous post on this topic, the Supreme Court has extended the old law prohibiting assisted suicide by four months (the government wanted six months - see article here). A further extension seems unlikely to be granted, given the circumstances. It seems more likely that the current law will expire without a new law coming into force (if only for a short period of time). However, since that would reflect badly on the government, the most likely outcome is for a new law to be passed.
Friday, 20 November 2015
Assisted Suicide Law v2
Before February 6th, 2016, what will happen with regards to Canada's assisted suicide law?
A new law will be passed regulating assisted suicide: 25%
The current law will be extended by the Supreme Court: 50%
The current law will expire: 25%
On February 6th, 2016, the current law regarding assisted suicide is set to expire, as per February's Supreme Court decision (see my previous post here, and the editorial here). The government is currently considering what to do, and has not ruled out asking the Supreme Court to extend the current law to allow more time for a new one to be drafted. I think that the government will probably make this request, and it will be granted additional time to draft a new law. Having said that, a wide variety of potential outcomes are possible, especially if the Supreme Court turns down the government's request for an extension.
A new law will be passed regulating assisted suicide: 25%
The current law will be extended by the Supreme Court: 50%
The current law will expire: 25%
On February 6th, 2016, the current law regarding assisted suicide is set to expire, as per February's Supreme Court decision (see my previous post here, and the editorial here). The government is currently considering what to do, and has not ruled out asking the Supreme Court to extend the current law to allow more time for a new one to be drafted. I think that the government will probably make this request, and it will be granted additional time to draft a new law. Having said that, a wide variety of potential outcomes are possible, especially if the Supreme Court turns down the government's request for an extension.
Monday, 28 September 2015
Tobacco Appeal
Will the appeal of the Quebec judgement against tobacco companies lead to a reduction in damages so that they are $1 billion or less?
Yes: 65%
(For the purposes of this question, all damages, fines, and surcharges count toward the total amount. The initial appeal is all that matters for this question)
A Quebec court recently ordered tobacco companies to pay $15 billion in damages to Quebec smokers (see article here). The tobacco companies are appealing the judgement. I think they will probably win, eventually; the original judgement seems to be somewhat of an outlier, and, as the article mentions, the companies won the initial battle over the immediate deposit of $1 billion.
Yes: 65%
(For the purposes of this question, all damages, fines, and surcharges count toward the total amount. The initial appeal is all that matters for this question)
A Quebec court recently ordered tobacco companies to pay $15 billion in damages to Quebec smokers (see article here). The tobacco companies are appealing the judgement. I think they will probably win, eventually; the original judgement seems to be somewhat of an outlier, and, as the article mentions, the companies won the initial battle over the immediate deposit of $1 billion.
Tuesday, 25 August 2015
New Brunswick Liquor Limits
Will the New Brunswick provincial court find that interprovincial liquor limits are unconstitutional in the case of Gerard Comeau?
Yes: 20%
(The initial decision of the court is all that matters for this question; results on subsequent appeals do not matter. This question is about the constitutionality of liquor limits, not the judgement against Comeau per se. A partial finding of unconstitutionality counts)
Gerald Comeau, a New Brunswick resident, is currently challenging a New Brunswick law which limits importation of alcohol into New Brunswick from other provinces (see story here). He had been caught transporting alcohol into New Brunswick from Quebec by the RCMP.
This sort of case seems like a tough fight for the defendants. The law in question has been around for a long time, as have interprovincial trade barriers more generally. The Supreme Court seems to have acquiesced to such barriers in a 1921 decision. Part of the purpose of this sort of case is to generate discussion about the law in question, even if the case itself is ultimately unsuccessful.
Yes: 20%
(The initial decision of the court is all that matters for this question; results on subsequent appeals do not matter. This question is about the constitutionality of liquor limits, not the judgement against Comeau per se. A partial finding of unconstitutionality counts)
Gerald Comeau, a New Brunswick resident, is currently challenging a New Brunswick law which limits importation of alcohol into New Brunswick from other provinces (see story here). He had been caught transporting alcohol into New Brunswick from Quebec by the RCMP.
This sort of case seems like a tough fight for the defendants. The law in question has been around for a long time, as have interprovincial trade barriers more generally. The Supreme Court seems to have acquiesced to such barriers in a 1921 decision. Part of the purpose of this sort of case is to generate discussion about the law in question, even if the case itself is ultimately unsuccessful.
Thursday, 18 June 2015
Calypso Fine
Q156: How much will Calypso water park pay in fines for its 2011-2012 safety violations?
Less than $100,000: 10%
$100,000 to $400,000: 30%
$400,000 to $1,000,000: 50%
More than $1,000,000: 10%
Calypso water park is currently on trial for a series of safety violations in 2011 and 2012 (see article here). It has already been found guilty, and the trial is currently in the sentencing phase. The prosecution is asking for $850,000, the defence for $125,000. I think that the judge will likely choose something between those two values, but is slightly more likely to go for a larger fine than a smaller one.
Less than $100,000: 10%
$100,000 to $400,000: 30%
$400,000 to $1,000,000: 50%
More than $1,000,000: 10%
Calypso water park is currently on trial for a series of safety violations in 2011 and 2012 (see article here). It has already been found guilty, and the trial is currently in the sentencing phase. The prosecution is asking for $850,000, the defence for $125,000. I think that the judge will likely choose something between those two values, but is slightly more likely to go for a larger fine than a smaller one.
Saturday, 13 June 2015
Ottawa OMB Appeal
Q151: Will the city of Ottawa succeed in its appeal of the OMB ruling on the Centretown Community Design Plan?
Yes: 30%
(For a "yes" answer, the city must win at the lowest court level (the Divisional Court). Further appeals do not matter.)
The City of Ottawa is appealing an OMB decision that restricted its ability to decide building heights in its Official Plan (see press release here). I don't have any solid information about how likely this appeal is to succeed (which is hard to tell from the city's press release). However, I have the vague sense that it is more likely to fail than not; the City may just be appealing the ruling for political reasons, and not because they expect to win.
Yes: 30%
(For a "yes" answer, the city must win at the lowest court level (the Divisional Court). Further appeals do not matter.)
The City of Ottawa is appealing an OMB decision that restricted its ability to decide building heights in its Official Plan (see press release here). I don't have any solid information about how likely this appeal is to succeed (which is hard to tell from the city's press release). However, I have the vague sense that it is more likely to fail than not; the City may just be appealing the ruling for political reasons, and not because they expect to win.
Friday, 8 May 2015
SC Drug Sentences
Q117: Will the Supreme Court of Canada find that mandatory minimum sentences for drug crimes are unconstitutional?
Yes: 70%
The Supreme Court has agreed to hear a BC appeal relating to mandatory minimum sentencing for drug offences. The original judge found that such sentences could constitute "cruel and unusual punishment", but this was overturned by the BC Court of Appeal.
Based on previous Supreme Court decisions (such as that relating to mandatory minimum sentences for gun crimes), I think that the Supreme Court will probably decide that mandatory minimum sentences for drug crimes are also unconstitutional.
Yes: 70%
The Supreme Court has agreed to hear a BC appeal relating to mandatory minimum sentencing for drug offences. The original judge found that such sentences could constitute "cruel and unusual punishment", but this was overturned by the BC Court of Appeal.
Based on previous Supreme Court decisions (such as that relating to mandatory minimum sentences for gun crimes), I think that the Supreme Court will probably decide that mandatory minimum sentences for drug crimes are also unconstitutional.
Monday, 4 May 2015
Baltimore Officer Guilt/Jail Time
Q113: Will any of the six officers charged in the death of Freddie Gray be found guilty, and if so, will any face jail time?
Yes, and will face jail time: 40%
Yes, but will not face jail time: 20%
No: 40%
(A plea bargain counts as guilty. The initial verdict is all that matters, even if it is overturned on appeal. Further charges against these officers or other officers do not count for this question)
Six Baltimore police officers have been charged in the death of Freddie Gray, who was taken into police custody (see story here). The charges seem to have been unexpectedly fast and serious (I was going to predict the likelihood of charges, but the officers were charged before I had the chance to).
From the news coverage of the story, I have the impression that it will be difficult to get a conviction, especially a serious conviction that would result in jail time. Police officers in these sorts of cases seem to rarely be convicted. Still, this case might be an exception, and the number of charges and officers charged will make convictions easier.
Yes, and will face jail time: 40%
Yes, but will not face jail time: 20%
No: 40%
(A plea bargain counts as guilty. The initial verdict is all that matters, even if it is overturned on appeal. Further charges against these officers or other officers do not count for this question)
Six Baltimore police officers have been charged in the death of Freddie Gray, who was taken into police custody (see story here). The charges seem to have been unexpectedly fast and serious (I was going to predict the likelihood of charges, but the officers were charged before I had the chance to).
From the news coverage of the story, I have the impression that it will be difficult to get a conviction, especially a serious conviction that would result in jail time. Police officers in these sorts of cases seem to rarely be convicted. Still, this case might be an exception, and the number of charges and officers charged will make convictions easier.
Friday, 1 May 2015
Omar Khadr Release
Q111: When will Omar Khadr be released?
Before May 31: 50%
Between June 1st and December 31st: 25%
Never or After January 1st: 25%
(Release on bail, or other forms of conditional release, count.)
Omar Khadr is currently serving an 8-year sentence in Alberta for his part in fighting the Americans in Afghanistan. However, he recently won bail in the course of an appeal of the conviction. The Canadian government is appealing the granting of bail. If he is released on bail, it will probably be sometime after May 5th. If he doesn't get bail, he may also be released as the result of a parole hearing in June.
I think Khadr will probably be released on bail in May, as this is really the default position now that he has won bail. If he isn't released on bail, he is still quite likely to be released on parole (or for some other reason).
Before May 31: 50%
Between June 1st and December 31st: 25%
Never or After January 1st: 25%
(Release on bail, or other forms of conditional release, count.)
Omar Khadr is currently serving an 8-year sentence in Alberta for his part in fighting the Americans in Afghanistan. However, he recently won bail in the course of an appeal of the conviction. The Canadian government is appealing the granting of bail. If he is released on bail, it will probably be sometime after May 5th. If he doesn't get bail, he may also be released as the result of a parole hearing in June.
I think Khadr will probably be released on bail in May, as this is really the default position now that he has won bail. If he isn't released on bail, he is still quite likely to be released on parole (or for some other reason).
Thursday, 30 April 2015
BC Teacher Rights
Q110: Will the BC Court of Appeal rule that 2002 provincial legislation on class size and composition violated teachers' charter rights?
Yes: 60%
The BC Court of Appeal is expected to rule today on whether 2002 provincial legislation unconstitutionally restricted teachers' collective bargaining rights (see article here). The lower BC.Supreme Court has ruled that it did. The provincial premier, Christy Clark, expects that the Court of Appeal will overturn the BC.Supreme Court's judgement.
I think that the Court of Appeal will probably side with the lower court, as this is the most common outcome. The premier's comments may just be bravado.
Yes: 60%
The BC Court of Appeal is expected to rule today on whether 2002 provincial legislation unconstitutionally restricted teachers' collective bargaining rights (see article here). The lower BC.Supreme Court has ruled that it did. The provincial premier, Christy Clark, expects that the Court of Appeal will overturn the BC.Supreme Court's judgement.
I think that the Court of Appeal will probably side with the lower court, as this is the most common outcome. The premier's comments may just be bravado.
Saturday, 25 April 2015
Yukon French School SC
Q105: Will the Supreme Court rule that Yukon's French school board has the power to control its own enrolment policy?
Yes: 60%
(A retrial will count as a "yes")
Yukon's French school board (which currently operates one school in Whitehorse) has sued the Yukon government, over a number of issues. The main issue is over admissions policy; the school board wants to admit more students who are not the children or grandchildren of French speakers. The case is currently before the Supreme Court on appeal (see articles here and here). The original case in 2011 was successful, but was overturned by appeal by the Yukon Supreme Court. A similar case in the N.W.T. resulted in a victory for the government in the N.W.T. Court of Appeal (see here). However, the Supreme Court recently ruled in favour of a Vancouver francophone school.
I think that the appeal will probably be successful; this case seems to be fairly similar to the successful Vancouver case. However, this is not certain, given the adverse Yukon Supreme Court ruling.
Yes: 60%
(A retrial will count as a "yes")
Yukon's French school board (which currently operates one school in Whitehorse) has sued the Yukon government, over a number of issues. The main issue is over admissions policy; the school board wants to admit more students who are not the children or grandchildren of French speakers. The case is currently before the Supreme Court on appeal (see articles here and here). The original case in 2011 was successful, but was overturned by appeal by the Yukon Supreme Court. A similar case in the N.W.T. resulted in a victory for the government in the N.W.T. Court of Appeal (see here). However, the Supreme Court recently ruled in favour of a Vancouver francophone school.
I think that the appeal will probably be successful; this case seems to be fairly similar to the successful Vancouver case. However, this is not certain, given the adverse Yukon Supreme Court ruling.
Monday, 6 April 2015
SC Medical Marijuana
Q90: Will the Supreme Court overturn the current federal law banning consumption of medical marijuana except in dried form?
Yes: 60%
The Supreme Court is currently considering the Smith case. The main issue is whether Canadians have a constitutional right to medical marijuana in non-dried forms. Both lower courts in BC found that they did, but the federal government has appealed to the Supreme Court. I think the Supreme Court will side with the lower courts, and overturn the current law.
Yes: 60%
The Supreme Court is currently considering the Smith case. The main issue is whether Canadians have a constitutional right to medical marijuana in non-dried forms. Both lower courts in BC found that they did, but the federal government has appealed to the Supreme Court. I think the Supreme Court will side with the lower courts, and overturn the current law.
Thursday, 26 February 2015
Supreme Court Human Smuggling
Q57: Will the Supreme Court of Canada overturn the current federal law on human smuggling?
Yes: 65%
No: 35%
(This question will be resolved as "yes" if (any part of) section 117 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act is ruled unconstitutional)
The Supreme Court is currently hearing arguments in five cases regarding human smuggling, mainly from Sri Lanka. The current law criminalizes helping an undocumented person enter Canada. This provision is the largest issue in the cases. At previous trials, the BC Supreme Court overturned the provision, but the BC Court of Appeal disagreed.
Based on the result in the assisted suicide case, I think that the Supreme Court will also overturn the current human smuggling law. That case had a similar judicial history, with the BC Supreme Court overturning the law and the BC Court of Appeal disagreeing.
Yes: 65%
No: 35%
(This question will be resolved as "yes" if (any part of) section 117 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act is ruled unconstitutional)
The Supreme Court is currently hearing arguments in five cases regarding human smuggling, mainly from Sri Lanka. The current law criminalizes helping an undocumented person enter Canada. This provision is the largest issue in the cases. At previous trials, the BC Supreme Court overturned the provision, but the BC Court of Appeal disagreed.
Based on the result in the assisted suicide case, I think that the Supreme Court will also overturn the current human smuggling law. That case had a similar judicial history, with the BC Supreme Court overturning the law and the BC Court of Appeal disagreeing.
Wednesday, 18 February 2015
Assisted Suicide Law
Q49: When will a law be passed regulating assisted suicide?
Before the next election: 30%
After the next election, but before the existing law is struck down: 50%
Not before the existing law is struck down: 20%
The Supreme Court of Canada recently struck down the ban on assisted suicide. The court gave Parliament 12 months to create a new law before the current law is struck down. The government does not seem to be moving quickly on the issue, and the conventional wisdom seems to be that a law will not be proposed before the next election. There is also some worry that no law will be drafted at all, and assisted suicide will be left unregulated (like abortion).
I think a new law before the next election is somewhat likely, but a law after the election is the most likely outcome. However, there might not be enough time after the election to pass a new law. The Conservatives and Liberals are about equally likely to pass a law after the election.
Before the next election: 30%
After the next election, but before the existing law is struck down: 50%
Not before the existing law is struck down: 20%
The Supreme Court of Canada recently struck down the ban on assisted suicide. The court gave Parliament 12 months to create a new law before the current law is struck down. The government does not seem to be moving quickly on the issue, and the conventional wisdom seems to be that a law will not be proposed before the next election. There is also some worry that no law will be drafted at all, and assisted suicide will be left unregulated (like abortion).
I think a new law before the next election is somewhat likely, but a law after the election is the most likely outcome. However, there might not be enough time after the election to pass a new law. The Conservatives and Liberals are about equally likely to pass a law after the election.
Wednesday, 28 January 2015
SC mandatory minimum sentences
Q28: Will the Supreme Court strike down mandatory minimum sentences for gun crimes?
Yes: 70%
No: 30%
The Supreme Court is currently considering a case relating to mandatory minimum sentences for gun crimes. The Ontario Court of Appeal previously ruled that the mandatory minimum sentences were "cruel and unusual punishment". I think the Supreme Court will probably rule the same way, but am somewhat uncertain about it.
Yes: 70%
No: 30%
The Supreme Court is currently considering a case relating to mandatory minimum sentences for gun crimes. The Ontario Court of Appeal previously ruled that the mandatory minimum sentences were "cruel and unusual punishment". I think the Supreme Court will probably rule the same way, but am somewhat uncertain about it.
Tuesday, 20 January 2015
SC Extradition Appeal
Q20: Will the Supreme Court strike down the extradition order of Anthony Barnaby and David Caplin?
Yes: 35%
No: 65%
Barnaby and Caplin, who are Canadian citizens (as far as I can tell), are accused of murdering a pair of women in New Hampshire in 1988. They faced three trials in 1989-1990, all of which ended in hung juries. Prosecutors there are trying to extradite them for a fourth trial. The Quebec Court of Appeal struck down that extradition order. The Supreme Court is hearing the government's appeal to reinstate the order. Hearings started on January 13.
The nature of Supreme Court cases is that there is no obvious result (or else the Supreme Court would never have heard the case). However, I think the Supreme Court will uphold the extradition order; my impression is that extradition orders are rarely overturned. The case of Hassan Diab might be relevant here. If the Court wanted to strike down the order, it could have just not heard the appeal.
Yes: 35%
No: 65%
Barnaby and Caplin, who are Canadian citizens (as far as I can tell), are accused of murdering a pair of women in New Hampshire in 1988. They faced three trials in 1989-1990, all of which ended in hung juries. Prosecutors there are trying to extradite them for a fourth trial. The Quebec Court of Appeal struck down that extradition order. The Supreme Court is hearing the government's appeal to reinstate the order. Hearings started on January 13.
The nature of Supreme Court cases is that there is no obvious result (or else the Supreme Court would never have heard the case). However, I think the Supreme Court will uphold the extradition order; my impression is that extradition orders are rarely overturned. The case of Hassan Diab might be relevant here. If the Court wanted to strike down the order, it could have just not heard the appeal.
Tuesday, 13 January 2015
Supreme Court Assisted Suicide
Q13: Will the Supreme Court overturn the Canadian criminal code statute against assisted suicide?
Yes: 50%
No: 50%
(Definition note: A partial overturning of the law counts as a "yes")
The Supreme Court is currently deliberating the Carter case (see coverage here). The plaintiffs in that case would like the court to overturn the current law against assisted suicide. Based on media stories, it is not clear what the decision will be. There was a previous (rather close) decision in 1993 which confirmed the current law.
I am very unsure how this case will be decided, so am going to give equal odds to both outcomes.
Yes: 50%
No: 50%
(Definition note: A partial overturning of the law counts as a "yes")
The Supreme Court is currently deliberating the Carter case (see coverage here). The plaintiffs in that case would like the court to overturn the current law against assisted suicide. Based on media stories, it is not clear what the decision will be. There was a previous (rather close) decision in 1993 which confirmed the current law.
I am very unsure how this case will be decided, so am going to give equal odds to both outcomes.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)